Was Luis Sarria the real, secret trainer of Muhammad Ali?

Discussion in 'Classic Boxing Forum' started by Saintpat, Aug 26, 2020.


  1. Saintpat

    Saintpat Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    22,482
    24,585
    Jun 26, 2009
    It’s in the text of the story. There’s a paragraph that begins “Angelo Dundee ...” saying he was working Ellis’ corner (fight film certainly verifies this) and soon after that it talks about Ali bringing in Wiley.
     
  2. Saintpat

    Saintpat Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    22,482
    24,585
    Jun 26, 2009
    Hmmm. “Some people.” None named. None quoted.

    Yes, Sarria was his conditioning coach. The article talks of what has already been acknowledged: putting Ali through exercises and calisthenics like any good conditioning coach would. And massaging Ali’s body. Like any masseuse would.

    Does it mention him installing a game plan for a fight? Does it mention him showing Ali how to use his boxing gifts in any way? No, of course it doesn’t.

    I also don’t buy this idea that he was really training Ali but afraid people might notice he existed so kept his identity secret — at the same time he was training Luis Rodriguez, a unified welterweight champion. Like no one in Cuba or America would notice him in that role? If he’s worried about Castro (or his minions) the LAST place he’d want to be is in Rodriguez’s corner because if Cubans were paying attention to boxing they damned sure weren’t overlooking the best boxer of the time from their own country.

    “He’s quiet” doesn’t mean “he’s afraid to step outside because someone might notice him.” Lots of people are quiet. Doesn’t mean they’re hiding. If he was, he did the worst job of hiding in the history of hiding, considering he had his photo taken so often giving the most recognized athlete in the entire world a rub-down, and carrying a bucket to his corner. You can’t have it both ways.

    People have bought into this myth about Dundee being absent because later in his career he showed up just for camps. He was a ‘hired gun’ by many fighters — he came in, polished them up, installed the game plan and worked the corner. But Ali, later in his career, wasn’t in the gym every day ... he was in the gym when he was in camp. Just as Dundee was. And the rest of the team.

    But 100 percent without question Dundee was there at the Fifth Street Gym early in Ali’s career when he was in the gym every day. There’s photographic evidence. There’s video evidence. There’s writers mentioning it all over the place. Yes, occasionally Dundee might be away for a weekend to work a corner of another fighter or something, but he was in the Fifth Street Gym basically every day. That’s why Jimmy Ellis had to relocate from Louisville — so he could be trained by Dundee and be there. That’s why Ali lived in Miami during that time of his career ... he didn’t take three months off between his 11th and 12th fights and then start a “camp.” He trained, he fought, he went back to the gym after to get ready for the next one. Maybe took a week off, or a few days.

    You think Thomas Hearns was in the gym every day with Manny by his side teaching him to box by the time he fought Hagler? Or do you think they had camp to prepare for the fight and that’s when Manny would work with him? How is that different from Dundee?
     
    Last edited: Aug 27, 2020
  3. Saintpat

    Saintpat Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    22,482
    24,585
    Jun 26, 2009
    Muhammad Ali on Angelo Dundee:

    “He’s one of the best in the world. You see, a real TRAINER, when he gets a real fighter, he don’t have to train him, just COACH HIM ON WHAT TO DO and who he’s fighting and WHAT TYPE STYLE TO FIGHT, what to look for, WHAT HIS WEAK POINTS ARE.

    “But to drill you every day on how to punch, I had that when I got to him.”

    This is The Greatest, a man who hired Dundee and worked with him from the start to the end of his professional career, saying Dundee was one of the best in the world and explaining what the role of a TRAINER is. Notice he doesn’t mention giving massages and conducting calisthenics, which is what Sarria did.

    Ask yourself why Ali didn’t answer this question something like, “Dundee wasn’t my trainer. Sarria was my real trainer. Let me tell you about him.”

    In fact, he never mentions Sarria as near as I can tell ever.

    Don’t believe the quote? Watch it yourself:

    This content is protected
     
  4. Richard M Murrieta

    Richard M Murrieta Now Deceased 2/4/25 Full Member

    22,635
    30,347
    Jul 16, 2019
    Joe Martin the Police Officer was Muhammad Ali's first trainer in 1954, when Ali learned how to box, someone stole his bicycle. Archie Moore was Ali's trainer following the 1960 Olympic games, at the request of the Louisville Group. Ali did not like the discipline of Moore, kind of like Wax On, Wax Off. So he went to Angelo Dundee. Ali did have various corner men throughout his career. Chickie Ferrera, and Luis Sarria, to name a few.
     
    choklab likes this.
  5. Dubblechin

    Dubblechin Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    24,314
    17,851
    Jun 25, 2014
    Boxers in the 1960s and 1970s didn't have 'conditioning coaches.' (LOL) That's a relatively modern term.

    Sarria worked with Ali every day in camp. Got him in shape. Made him run. Made him do situps and pushups. Made him hit the bags. Watched him spar. Put him thru his exercises. Rubbed him down every day of camp. That is a trainer.

    If you hired a trainer, that's what a trainer would do for you. And, in the 70s, Wali Muhammad came on board and did much of the same things.

    It's clear, Dundee was a hands-on trainer with ALOT of the other boxers he handled in the 1950s and 1960s. He even served as manager and trainer for a many.

    But it's not clear he had the same role with Ali. Hell, Archie Moore trained a young Ali for a while before they actually had a falling out and fought each other.

    What training was Dundee responsible for when it came to Ali? How did he "train" Ali? Be specific. Because there are a THOUSAND quotes from everyone saying Ali did what he wanted and Ali was the boss. Did Dundee hire the sparring partners? Did Dundee tell Ali how many miles to run? Did Dundee select the opponents?

    People on here said Dundee "came up with the fight plans." How did Ali's fight plans differ from fight to fight exactly? When he was young, he jabbed and moved. When he was older and couldn't, he'd take shots on the ropes and then jab and move for a minute or two a round.

    What strategies did Dundee come up with? (LOL) Be specific.

    You seem very dismissive of Sarria, who everyone credits with getting Ali in shape and extending his boxing career. Sarria clearly was not THE MAN IN CHARGE. He didn't even speak English. But, really, nobody was more in charge of Ali's training than Ali himself.

    Dundee showed up for a couple weeks before the fight to earn his check, talk to reporters, watch Ali train and work the corner for the fight. He was HEAD TRAINER in name only. He couldn't even stop the Holmes fight until Ali's manager gave the go-ahead to call it.

    If he was actually the HEAD trainer, he should've been run out of the sport for allowing Ali to get in the ring against Holmes and Berbick. He certainly did a bang-up job training Ali for those. (rolls eyes)

    And Ali was living in Chicago by the mid 60s, because he wanted to be near Elijah Muhammad after he converted to Islam. That's where he met his second wife. And that's where they lived.

    Ali was a pro for 21 years. You can count the years he "walked" to a gym every day in Miami on a couple fingers.
     
    Last edited: Aug 27, 2020
  6. bcr

    bcr Well-Known Member Full Member

    2,554
    1,421
    Dec 21, 2013
    I don't think he's being dismissive of Sarria, is simply that the previous guy called Dundee overrated and said that Sarria was the secret trainer of Ali when Ali and Sarria himself say that Dundee was the head trainer, so, why are people even arguing about it?

    You're using your own standards to define a "head trainer", not stopping a fight or letting a fighter sign a certain match up doesn't take away your position as head trainer, he was literally the guy that ran the camp for Ali and all the other fighters, is there anything else to discuss?, was Alex Ariza the head coach of Pacquiao?.

    I mean, just literally refer to Sarria:

    “Angelo and the sparring partners earned their money but there were many in the camp that earned high salaries and did absolutely nothing…Few cared for him as a human being.”

    “I was training Luis…” Sarria said, “And Ali spoke to me, but I do not speak English. Then he spoke to Angelo and he told me Ali wanted me to massage him…Our friendship started that day.”

    He trained a lot of succesful fighters, both amateur and pro but he wasn't the head coach for Dundee's fighters, if you have ever been to a boxing gym, is not weird at all to have an specific trainer guide you through a certain part of the training everyday, that doesn't make him the head coach or the guy that runs the gym.
     
    Richard M Murrieta likes this.
  7. Saintpat

    Saintpat Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    22,482
    24,585
    Jun 26, 2009
    Early in Ali’s career, he lived in Miami. Are you saying Dundee only popped into his own gym right before Ali fights?

    The term existed because there are quotes, even in the article you cited, where they say Sarria was in charge of Ali’s calisthenics — like doing his freaking sit-ups and, yes, making sure he did his running (you think Ali didn’t know how to run or that he needed to, lol) and such. And rubbed him down. That’s it. That’s NOT what a head trainer does.

    You know what a head trainer does with Muhammad Ali? What MUHAMMAD ALI said a trainer does — and specified exactly what Dundee did. I typed out the quote. I linked the video. Do I need to draw a picture?

    No, I don’t know exactly what each game plan for every single Ali fight was. Nobody living does. But I know he fought — within his style — differently from fight to fight. If you can’t see that, you need to start over. Did he fight Jimmy Young exactly the way he fought Ken Norton? No. He changed punching axis from fight to fight to fit the opponent. He used uppercuts more against Frazier than he did against Foreman. He emphasized the right lead more against Foreman (see the first round especially to look at what he intended to do gameplan-wise before he adjusted to the rope-a-dope) than against Quarry, where he was moving around more and using the jab. Etc. Etc. You think every Ali fight is a carbon copy of the other? No it wasn’t.

    And you know what Dundee did? Hmm. Maybe what MUHAMMAD ALI said he did. In ALI’s words:

    “You see, a real TRAINER, when he gets a real fighter, he don’t have to train him, just COACH HIM ON WHAT TO DO and who he’s fighting and WHAT TYPE STYLE TO FIGHT, what to look for, WHAT HIS WEAK POINTS ARE.”

    So are you saying Dundee didn’t do what Ali did? He told him “what type style to fight” and “coached him on what to do” and who he’s fighting. You know what that is? That’s game plan. That’s not exercises.

    And you only underscored my points on Ali living in Chicago (and at some point New Jersey, I’m not sure where else): after he got to a certain point and wasn’t fighting every month or so (like he was when he lived in Miami and came to the Fifth Street Gym practically every day, to be greeted by a guy named Angelo Dundee, who held the title of trainer (not masseuse or conditioning coach), he trained when he went to camp. And guess who was there for every camp: Angelo Dundee (you’re the one who wants to make it like he was largely absent from Ali’s training, but he showed up for training camp — are you saying Sarria commuted to Chicago daily between fights to work Ali out? No, he did his job, also, in camp).

    You say no one had a conditioning coach in Ali’s day. Guess who did? Ali. It’s plain and everyone says that was Sarria’s job. Maybe he was the first conditioning coach in boxing history. Someone was, right? So they invented a position because they were ahead of the rest of the world and found the most qualified exercise/conditioning guy was right there under their nose and gave him that role.
     
    Last edited: Aug 27, 2020
    Richard M Murrieta likes this.
  8. Dubblechin

    Dubblechin Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    24,314
    17,851
    Jun 25, 2014
    I know Dundee trained a lot of successful fighters. I know he was very hands-on with some of his fighters.

    But what did Dundee do for Ali specifically as a trainer?

    Did he teach Ali to hold his hands low? Did he teach him to lean straight back from punches? Did he tell him to head hunt and rarely, if ever, throw body punches?

    Because Ali fought the same way every fight, until he couldn't like that anymore. Then he'd improvise.

    Dundee didn't get Ali in shape. Sarria did.

    Did he pick his title challengers? What amazing "strategies" did Dundee come up with from fight to fight with Ali that helped Ali hold the title ... other than pushing a blind Ali off the stool in the Liston fight and telling Ali to "run" ... because Dundee thought the Black Muslims would pummel Dundee if the fight was stopped?

    Dundee worked Ali's corner. He was the head cornerman. That was Dundee's job, in essence. The guy Ali brought in for the Ellis fight was there to be the head cornerman. Ali fought like he normally did against Ellis. When Dundee came back, Ali fight the same way he did when Dundee wasn't there.

    There was no head trainer. Muhammad Ali was Ali's head trainer. Sarria spent more time with him in the gym working Ali than anyone else did.

    I don't know why everyone is bashing Klompton over this. It's all nitpicking, really.
     
  9. Dubblechin

    Dubblechin Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    24,314
    17,851
    Jun 25, 2014
    What did Dundee coach Ali to do? When did Dundee tell Ali to change his style before a fight? When did Dundee scout an opponent and tell Ali "this is where you MUST attack."

    It's nonsense. Dundee was there to be the chief cornerman. Sarria was there every day to get Ali in shape.

    But Ali trained when he wanted to train, boxed in the style that everyone said was the wrong way to fight, and did what he wanted during fights.

    There was no head guy in charge of Ali's gym or fight performances, except Ali.
     
    Last edited: Aug 27, 2020
    choklab likes this.
  10. Saintpat

    Saintpat Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    22,482
    24,585
    Jun 26, 2009
    Who says he told him to change his style? He worked within the style he had. He emphasized whatever he thought needed to be emphasized for each opponent. Just like Ali said he did. Or are you saying Ali was lying to cover up the fact that Sarria was his “real” trainer?

    (And if so, what did Sarria do to change his style? Be specific. And why didn’t Sarria stop the Holmes fight? Why didn’t he walk away and tell Ali to retire? He’s the man, lol, so why aren’t you aiming that kind of criticism at him?)

    You want it from Muhammad Ali’s mouth? Read this from Sports Illustrated — Ali (then Clay) says he knew how to fight when he came to Dundee, but Dundee found mistakes, showed him how to throw the right uppercut. Turned the jab from a flick to a weapon. And left hook. And body punches.

    This isn’t me saying it. This is Ali saying it.

    https://vault.si.com/vault/1965/05/24/man-in-the-champs-corner

    Now of course you will take this to mean that Dundee never taught him anything else, that for the next 15 years or whatever he never made another suggestion that Ali followed. Of course. Because it doesn’t fit your narrative.

    Just like in this article Dundee is with Ali (Clay at the time) in the Fifth Street Gym BEFORE they head to training camp. Well how can that be? You say Dundee only showed up for a few days before the fight.

    Just like Dundee tells at this stage (just as he says later in other anecdotes) that to get Ali to do what he wanted in sparring he had to compliment him on how well he was doing it. Ali hasn’t thrown a jab all day. Dundee knows he needs to jab in this fight. Dundee tells him how great his jab is looking. Next round, or next day, Ali comes in and throws jabs. Because Dundee knows how to reach talent. And direct talent. And, yes, teach things to talented people.

    What you can’t seem to comprehend is that corner work is an extension of training. You don’t walk into the ring with a bucket with no game plan and just make things up. Sometimes you adjust, but you don’t go in with a blank sheet. So the things he says in the corner are an extension of what’s emphasized in training.

    Ray Leonard (remember, Dundee didn’t train him, only hired the trainers and told them what to work on ... which is basically being the head trainer once removed and subcontracting the labor part) threw like 23 right hands in the first round against Benitez. Misses every one of them. Dundee tells him forget the right hand, work the left. “But he’s right there,” Ray protests. Dundee says forget the right hand, work the left. Ray goes out in the next round and works the left and gradually breaks down El Radar until he can land those right hands. You think Dundee made up all that on the spot?

    Ray fights Roberto Duran’s fight in Montreal. Loses. When the rematch comes, Dundee makes it clearer in interviews and press conferences that this time Leonard will use his lateral movement, will box Duran, make Duran fight Ray’s fight. Now you want to say Dundee had nothing to do with that? He told everybody including Duran what they were going to do before the first bell rang and Ray went out and executed it.

    But you want to follow some myth that Dundee has nothing to do with all of that. Just a guy who carries a bucket.

    So if you’re trying to say Dundee never taught Ali anything, you’re calling Ali a liar. If you’re saying Dundee wasn’t Ali’s head trainer, you’re calling Ali a liar. If you’re saying Sarria was Ali’s trainer, you’re calling Ali and Sarria and Dundee and Ferdie Pacheco a liar.
     
    Last edited: Aug 27, 2020
  11. bcr

    bcr Well-Known Member Full Member

    2,554
    1,421
    Dec 21, 2013
    You're really underestimating what a trainer does, then I guess all boxers should coach themselves after learning the fundamentals since they already know what to do just like Shumenov did. Do you think that the Ali that got almost knocked out by Banks and Henry Cooper and that almost losses against Doug Jones was close to the man that made Liston quit?. Most of the adjustments that a trainer does are really small things like the way you turn your body into a punch or something as simple as the position of your back foot, those small things matter a lot and are the things that fighters work on when they get a pro trainer.

    There was a head trainer, Angelo Dundee, he ran the camp, he gave the instructions in the corner and his fighters (and Sarria) knew that he was the head coach, again, it's not even an argument, it's a fact, the 5th Street Gym was owned by Chris Dundee and his brother Angelo was the head coach, that's a fact.

    Do you think that Robert Garcia, Freddie Roach or Abel Sanchez are all over every single fighter at their gym all the time?, they're not, but when fight night arrives, they work the corner and their fighters always refer to them as their head coach.

    Again, you're mixing facts with opinion, Ali, Sarria, Leonard, Pacheco, they all knew that Dundee was the head coach, they all praised him for that, people are shitting on Klompton for saying that Dundee is overrated and using an argument completely made on the spot, because Sarria nor Ali ever claimed that Sarria was his secret trainer, he was part of the team and got his credit as such.

    Just go to any regular gym, ask for the head coach and see if the guy is working with every single fighter during every step of the preparation. They're not.

    Sarria himself said that Ali was training with DUNDEE when he spoke to him for the first time and he couldn't even understand him.

    It doesn't matter if you don't think that Dundee had great strategies, according to his boxers, to his team, to Sarria, to the boxing world, he was the head coach at the 5th Street Gym.

    Freddie Roach is the head coach of Pacquiao, it doesn't matter how many rounds he does on the mitts with Buboi, it doesn't matter how many sit ups and how many miles he ran with Ariza, Roach is the one who runs the Wild Card gym and the corner.
     
    Last edited: Aug 27, 2020
    Saintpat likes this.
  12. choklab

    choklab cocoon of horror Full Member

    27,669
    7,623
    Dec 31, 2009
    I agree 100%. Bundini was a celebrated spare part. Entirely Necessary in the way a maraca player might be during an earthquake. The silhouette during the credits of a bond film...
     
    Richard M Murrieta likes this.
  13. Dubblechin

    Dubblechin Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    24,314
    17,851
    Jun 25, 2014
    I know what trainers do. I'm not underestimating anyone.

    I know Dundee trained and managed and made a huge imprint on many fighters. I give him full credit for that. But you seem to want to twist this into some indictment of all trainers or how Dundee ran his gym. This isn't even an indictment of Dundee.

    Ali ran Ali's camp. Others got Ali in shape, which everyone admits happened, Dundee included. Dundee was brought in to be the chief cornerman before fights, which he was. That was the setup.

    When did Dundee say he taught Ali anything? When did Ali say he learned something new from Dundee? Even when Ali said he had a new "Anchor Punch" which stopped Liston, he said he learned it from Steppin Fetchit, an old comic. Moore left as Ali's trainer because Ali wouldn't listen to him.

    What did Ali work on with Dundee? Holding his hands low? Throwing zero body punches? Leaning straight back to avoid a punch? What did they work on?

    When did Dundee come up with the big strategy to win a fight? Name the fight? Any fight? Ali fought the same style the same way throughout the 60s. And when he got too old to do that in the 70s, he fought off the ropes (usually with Dundee telling him not).

    When did anyone give Dundee credit for anything other than intentionally making the rip in Ali's glove bigger against Cooper, which resulted in Cooper getting cut a minute or two later or pushing Ali out of the corner when he was blind?

    I'm being serious. Fighters talk about how trainers teach them things all the time. What did Dundee teach Ali? Anyone?

    Sarria got Ali in shape and didn't speak to anyone. Dundee worked the corner and talked to the press guys.

    The real head trainer was Ali. If Ali didn't want to get in shape, he didn't. And if Ali didn't want to listen to his corner during a fight, he didn't. And Ali fought like he wanted to fight, holding his hands down, not punching to the body, pulling straight back from shots, sitting on the ropes taking blows, doing everything he wasn't supposed to do.

    I'm not talking about Dundee's relationships with any other fighters, or any other trainer's relationships with their fighters, just Dundee's relationship with Ali.

    Sarria got Ali in shape. Dundee was there to step up and work the corner on fight night.
     
    Last edited: Aug 27, 2020
    choklab likes this.
  14. choklab

    choklab cocoon of horror Full Member

    27,669
    7,623
    Dec 31, 2009
    I think it was exactly like that!
     
    Richard M Murrieta likes this.
  15. mcvey

    mcvey VIP Member Full Member

    97,062
    27,864
    Jun 2, 2006
    Cooper was cut on the right eye in the 2nd rd and badly gashed on the left eyebrow in the 3rd rd. Cooper wasn't knocked down till the end of the 4th rd and Dundee drew the split stitching around the thumb of the glove to the attention of the referee between the 4th and 5th rds .